About

Virtual Health Library on Traditional Complementary and Integrative Medicine (VHL TCIM)

The Virtual Health Library on Traditional, Complementary, and Integrative Medicine (VHL TCIM) is a thematic VHL which specializes in Traditional, Complementary, and Integrative Medicine (TCIM) and its related health practices.

The VHL TCIM applies the VHL model of network collaboration.

The VHL TCIM aims to promote the visibility, access, use and generation of scientific, technical, and educational contents that contribute to the promotion, development and integration of the TCIM in the health services and systems in the Americas Region, through the collaboration of stakeholders.

Lines of Action: 
  • To promote open access to scientific, technical information and evidence on TCIM
  • Promotion of informed decision-making, using the best available knowledge and evidence on TCIM
  • Facilitate the exchange of knowledge and collaboration amongst stakeholders
  • Experience exchange and visibility of good practices

The VHL TCIM is a collaborative and participative virtual space, developed and managed by the Traditional, Complementary, and Integrative Medicine Network for the Americas (TCIM Americas Network). This Network was established by the cooperation between institutions and organizations involved in the training, regulation, promotion, research development, and provision of TCIM services. The Pan-American Health Organization/ World Health Organization (PAHO/WHO), by means of the Latin-American and Caribbean System on Health Sciences Information (BIREME/PAHO/WHO), works as the articulator and facilitator of the aforementioned Network.

The VHL TCIM is aligned with a series of thethe WHO and PAHO/WHO policy strategies, including the WHO Traditional Medicine Strategy 2014-2023, the PAHO/WHO Ethnicity and Health Policy, and the PAHO/WHO Strategy for Universal Access to Health and Universal Health Coverage (Resolution CD53.R14), among others (for more details, see "The Thematic area”).

VHL TCIM Background

The idea of the VHL TCIM started from an agreement established between BIREME, PAHO/WHO Representation in Nicaragua, and the Instituto de Medicina Natural y Terapias Complementarias (IMNTC), from Nicaragua, in 2015, with the objective of integrating other countries.

After a series of joint actions among the key stakeholders, the project for the development of the VHL TCIM started to consolidate. VHL TCIM started to consolidate. During this initial phase, the first sketches of the portal were developed, infometrics was conducted, and reference documents were identified. The Nicaragua team conducted an initial inventory of sources of information, initially categorizing themes related to TCIM and identifying possible allies. BIREME team used the VHL model to develop a thematic TCIM portal; and developed applications (services) to integrate information and educational resources of national and international sources of information from the area into a portal available on the web. Additionally, BIREME led capacity-building processes for the collaboration Network and the initiative coordinators.

The VHL TCIM project was presented at the Regional meeting “Advancing Towards Universal Health, Contributions of Traditional and Complementary Medicine”, which took place in Managua, Nicaragua, on June 6-8, 2017, and that was a call for action convened by PAHO/WHO Regional Office. During the meeting, delegates from several countries proposed the creation of a collaboration network in TCIM for the Americas. It was then when the VHL TCIM project took off.

The TCIM Americas Network took over management of the VHL TCIM, and the initial effort started to have a regional scope. The collaborators of the TCIM Americas Network have developed all the contents of the VHL TCIM portal collaboratively. They have met with national health authorities, healthcare institutions, academic institutions, researchers, non-government organizations, and others, to make this project feasible.

About the TCIM Network for the Americas

The Traditional, Complementary and Integrative Medicine Network for the Americas (TCIM Americas Network) is a collaborative initiative, created with the objective of interconnecting several stakeholders involved in the formulation of policies, regulation, training, promotion, practice, use and research of TCIM in the Americas. The aim is to develop a common agenda and advance in the integration of TCIM in healthcare systems and services according to each national context.

The TCIM Americas Network is an inclusive, horizontal-governance initiative, currently gathering several organizations from 15 countries of the Americas, and continuously growing. The TCIM Americas Network was established in June 2017 by a group of delegates in the Regional Meeting “Advancing Towards Universal Health: Contributions of Traditional and Complementary Medicine”, in Managua, Nicaragua (click here to know more about the event).

Since its establishment, the TCIM Americas Network took over the management of the Virtual Health Library on Traditional, Complementary, and Integrative Medicine (VHL TCIM). This Network is responsible for the content and development of the portal, and also, of the specialized TCIM database, with the technical support from BIREME/PAHO/WHO.

Mission

Vision

Objectives

Members

About the TCIM theme

The concept of “Traditional, Complementary, and Integrative Medicines” (TCIM) encompasses a series of medical systems, therapies, and health practices. What they all have in common is that they look at human beings, health, and disease as a whole. Some of these systems are part of the ancestral traditions and knowledge of millenary cultures; others are innovative propositions that promote a holistic view of life, health, disease processes, attention, care, recovery, rehabilitation, and also death.

The use of TCIM largely varies in between countries and contexts. In many countries, “traditional medicine is the main pillar of health services” (WHO, 2013), or it is used as a complement to biomedical (conventional) treatment. The WHO Traditional Medicine Strategy (2014-2023) recognizes that TCIM is “an important and often underestimated part of healthcare. It is practiced in almost all countries in the world, and its demand is increasing” (WHO, 2013).

The World Health Assembly and the Executive Board of the World Health Organization (WHO) have approved along the years a series of resolutions that reflect the agreement among Member States about the importance of preserving, promoting, investigating, regulating, and assuring quality of TCIM, as well as integrating it to national health systems. In 2014, the World Health Assembly approved the Resolution WHA67.18 about Traditional Medicine. Recently, in 2016, it approved Resolution WHA69.24 Strengthening Integrated, People-Centered Health Services that encourages Member States to integrate TCIM into health services, whenever possible, taking a holistic focus on health into consideration.

WHO has published an important number of documents about the theme, including policy instruments, norms for training in different practices/systems, nomenclature standards, as well as methodology investigation guides, guides for the development of information directed to the public, guides for medicinal plants conservation and use, and guides for processing and assuring the quality of herbal and homeopathic drugs. It has also developed and published global surveys about the regulation of herbal drugs and national TCIM policies, and documents about the intersection of TCIM in primary health care, among others.

The first WHO Traditional Medicine Strategy 2002-2005  focused on safety, efficacy, quality, and rational use of traditional and complementary medicine, and it was an important accomplishment that enabled significant advances for the integration of TCIM into health systems throughout the world. The strategy was updated in 2013, and published under the title “WHO Traditional Medicine Strategy 2014-2023”, with the objective of “helping Member States to develop dynamic policies and apply action plans that reinforce the role of [TCIM] in keeping people’s health”, harnessing the “potential contribution of [TCIM] to health, wellness, and people-centered healthcare”, promoting “the safe and effective use of [TCIM] through regulation and research, as well as the incorporation of products, practitioners and practices in health systems, whenever applicable”. Its three strategic objectives are:

  • To build the knowledge base for active TCIM management through appropriate national policies;
  • To strengthen quality assurance, safety, adequate use and effectiveness of TCIM through the regulation of its products, practices, and practitioners;
  • To promote universal health coverage by integrating TCI Medicine services into healthcare services and self-health care.

In the Americas, PAHO/WHO has led regional and national initiatives to promote TCIM. Some of these initiatives include: (1) Resolution CD37.R5, urges member states to promote the transformation of health systems and support the development of alternative models of care for indigenous populations and the development of investigation networks; (2) documentation of several traditional medicine systems and their relations with populations and national health systems; (3) creation of conceptual landmarks for the development of intercultural health models; (4) development of regional strategies to promote the integration of TCIM into national health systems; (5) facilitation of regional workshops to regulate on medicinal plants and TCIM policies; (6) implementation of the Indigenous Medicine and Therapies in Primary Healthcare Project. PAHO/WHO participated in the development of the first WHO Traditional Medicine Strategy (2002-2005).

Recently, PAHO/WHO adopted, through Resolution CSP29.R3, the Policy on Ethnicity and Health that proposes the implementation of actions with intercultural focus and the following priority lines for technical cooperation among Member States: a) to generate evidence, b) to call for action in policies, c) to foster social participation and strategic alliances, d) to recognize ancestral knowledge and traditional and complementary medicine, and e) to develop capabilities at all levels. This policy encourages Member states to promote public policies that address ethnicity as a social determinant of health; to foster better access to quality health services, promoting intercultural health models, systems and services, including the perspective of the ancestral and spiritual wisdom and practices of indigenous peoples, Afro-descendants, gipsies, and members of other ethnic groups; to promote the generation of knowledge and dedicated spaces for ancestral medicine and wisdom; to integrate the ethnical focus and vision of these people in the application of the action health plan in all policies (document CD53/10, Rev. 1 [2014]); and to promote intersectoral cooperation for the sustainable development of indigenous peoples, Afro-descendants, gipsies, and members of other ethnic groups.

It is equally important to highlight that the PAHO/WHO Strategy for Universal Access to health and Universal Health Coverage (Resolution CD53.R14) reaffirms the need to strengthen and/or develop health models focused on people in the communities, to meet the specific and different needs of the several population groups; and recognizes that respect to traditional medicine, as well as access and rational use of medication and other safe, effective, and quality health technologies continue to be a challenge for most of the Region countries.

This Universal Health Strategy also proposes to “structure or consolidate collaborative multidisciplinary health teams and strengthen resolutive capacity with access to information”; and “strengthen the professional and technical human resources profiles in health and/or introduce new profiles, coherent with the transformation or strengthening of the healthcare model.” In this sense, it is important to highlight that the Declaration of Alma-Ata recognized the importance of traditional medicine agents as participants of primary care teams.

Definitions

Traditional medicine
Traditional medicine has a long history. It is the total sum of the knowledge, skills and practices based on the theories, beliefs, and experiences indigenous to different cultures, whether explicable or not, used in the maintenance of health as well as in the prevention, diagnosis, improvement, or treatment of physical and mental illness.  (WHO)
Complementary medicine
The terms “complementary medicine” or “alternative medicine” refer to a broad set of health care practices that are not part of that country’s own tradition or conventional medicine, and are not fully integrated into the dominant health care system. They are used interchangeably with traditional medicine in some countries. (WHO) 
Traditional and Complementary medicine (TCM)
Traditional and complementary Medicine merges the terms “traditional medicine” and “complementary medicine”, and encompasses products, practices, and practitioners. (WHO)
Integrative Medicine
Integrative medicine and health reaffirms the importance of the relation between practitioner and patient, focuses on the whole person, is informed by evidence, and makes use of all appropriate therapeutic and lifestyle approaches, healthcare professionals and disciplines to achieve optimal health and healing. (The Academic Consortium for Integrative Medicine & Health). A type of care that combines conventional (standard) medicine with complementary and alternative therapies that have been shown to be safe and effective. The complementary and alternative practices treat the patient's mind, body, and spirit.  (National Cancer Institute)

VHL TCIM Website

The Virtual Health Library Traditional, Complementary and Integrative Medicine (VHL TCIM) is organized into sections

Main menu:
    • About VHL TCIM: this section brings information about the background of the VHL TCIM, its aims and projects; relation to PAHO/WHO policy instruments; information about the  TCIM Americas Network  (background, members, mission, vision, and objectives of the network); and information about TCIM topic.
    • Directory of Institutions:  this section brings an inventory (organized by countries) of the different bodies that work in the management/regulation, training, research, integration of TCIM into health systems. The organizations listed are sorted in the following categories: Health Authority, Academy (TCIM training and research), Healthcare Providers, and Public Health Program Implementing Staff, TCIM Collaboration Networks, Professional Associations/Consortia; Indigenous and Non-Government Organizations.
    • Regulation and Policies: this section brings information about the TCIM legislation and implementation models in the health systems of countries in the Americas, as well as regulation on TCIM practices, practitioners, and products.
    • Traditional Medicine in Ethnic Diversities:   In this section, you will find information on indigenous peoples, African-descendants and other ethnic diversity of the Americas, which includes a description of the health situation, their ancestral knowledge in health practices and traditional medicine, their own health models, relevant organizations and resources of interest.
    • Academic Consortium:  An initiative that started with the Brazilian Integrative Health Consortium and that is intended to expand to the region, looking forward to further development of an academic research consortium in each country. The subsection includes the universities that are part of the consortium, discussion and debate tools, research project records, and others.
TCIM Database Search Tool:
This section brings the search box for TCIM Database; the service enables searching by words, terms and/or phrases of the collection’s bibliographic references. There is also one option for advance research in the database. Click here for basic instructions on how to use it?
Highlights Section:
Located immediately under the main menu, this section brings important announcements for the theme, highlighting the most important events, key publications, capacity-building courses, new sections, and updates of the VHL TCIM, and important facts in the integration of TCIM the Americas´ region, among others.
Headlines Sections:
This section, located on the main portal page, brings tags to four lines of action:
  • Health Strengthening: This section brings health proposals, strategies, and models aimed to strengthen and promote health from the perspective of Traditional, Complementary, and Integrative Medicine, and related therapies and practices (TCIM)
  • Understanding TCIM: Section dedicated to general knowledge of TCIM, including definition, concepts, and evidence dossiers. It includes the thematic structure and terminology used to organize the VHL, its database (MOSAICO) and search tools.
  • Strengthening Research: This section includes a useful collection of relevant academic resources for researchers in training, junior and senior researchers. One of the purposes of VHL TCIM portal is to improve the skills in research in the field of TCIM.
  • Conceptual Models: This section is dedicated to the dialogue of knowledge, reflections, and exchanges about the diversity of health paradigms, approaches, and models that support and operate intervention proposals, healthcare, self-care, and the strengthening of health associated TCIM. It highlights the TCIM concepts and models developed in the Americas Region
News Section:
This section brings relevant news on TCIM from the communication media, relevant academic publications, and also from members of the TCIM Americas Network.
TCIM Infometrics:
The first infometrics was based on technical and scientific literature about Traditional Medicine and Complementary Therapies (TC&M) indexed in MEDLINE and LILACS database up to May 2017. Approximately 160 thousand bibliographic records were included in the analysis, in which they were distributed by article, journal, and country, type of study, language, and publication year. It is possible to combine the elements of each group to get the list of documents. The infometrics analysis is applicable to identify the concentration or gaps of the scientific production available about TCIM in the international literature. > > Link to infometrics.
Direct access:
This section offers access to search results in document sets based on a specific database or on a specific criterion, such as “systematic reviews.” It also brings direct access to other TCIM database, scientific evidence, clinical practice guides, protocols, reference publications, among others.
Links of interest:
This section offers links to other initiative related to the theme, with an emphasis on another website that follow VHL methodology. You can also find links to other reference pages, such as the WHO page on Traditional, Complementary, and Integrative Medicine.
Contact
This section brings contact information of the VHL TCIM website administrators and editors, as well as of the specialized database.

VHL TCIM Collection

The bibliographic collection of the VHL TCIM Americas, has two main sources: a) the harvest (through a search strategy) of existing databases (including Medline, LILACS, WHOLIS, mainly); b) the documents entered into the specialized database in TCIM of the Americas region (MOSAICO) that is being developed by BIREME with the support and management of the TCIM Americas Network. The documents (scientists and technicians) that are part of this collection have been published mostly in journals, but also includes books, theses, technical and non-conventional documents.

The TCIM Americas Network and BIREME team built the criteria selection for the documents that are being added to MOSAICO database, most of which are produced in academic institutions and government organizations. And also, they built a thematic structure to developed the different search strategies to compile the documents from different sources.

The collection started in June 2017, and the gathering of references was conducted based on a search strategy in the three databases of VHL Regional Portal:

LILACS - Latin-American and Caribbean Health Sciences Literature.

MEDLINE - International Health Sciences Literature (which also includes PubMed).

WHOLIS - WHO Library Database indexed in IRIS Repository

The search is made every week to update the VHL MTCI collection with new documents. Based on the results of a given search, a breakdown into categories is presented and works as a search filter such as a database, subtopics of interest, subject, journal, year of publication, country, and others.

At present, the BIREME team and the stakeholders of TCIM Americas Network have been reviewing the existing DeCS and MeSH terminology in the TCIM field to refine the search strategy for the collection of data. Additionally to improve document classification in VHL TCIM and in other databases and information search engines.

In the first phase, the search expression applied in VHL to select documents about the topic including the following terms in Spanish, English, and Portuguese:


ʺAlternative Medicineʺ OR ʺAlternative Therapiesʺ OR ʺAlternative Therapyʺ OR ʺComplementary Medicineʺ OR ʺComplementary Therapiesʺ OR ʺComplementary Therapiesʺ OR ʺComplementary Therapyʺ OR “Magnetismo Vegetal” OR “Medicina Complementar e Integrativa” OR “Medicina Complementar” OR “Medicina Complementaria e Integradora” OR “Medicina Complementaria” OR “Medicina Folclorica” OR “Medicina Indigena” OR “Medicina Integradora y Complementaria” OR “Medicina Integrativa e Complementar” OR “Medicina Popular” OR “Medicina Primitiva” OR ʺMedicina Alternativaʺ OR ʺMedicina Ancestralʺ OR ʺMedicina Holísticaʺ OR ʺMedicina Integrativaʺ OR ʺMedicina Naturalʺ OR ʺMedicina Tradicionalʺ OR ʺMedicina Tradicional Indígenaʺ OR ʺMedicinal and Cosmetic Plantʺ OR ʺMedicinal Herbʺ OR ʺMedicinal Herbsʺ OR ʺMedicinal Plantʺ OR ʺMedicinal Plantsʺ OR Ethnobotany OR Ethnomedicine OR Ethnopharmacology OR Fitoterapia OR ʺFolk Medicineʺ OR ʺFolk Remediesʺ OR ʺFolk Remedyʺ OR ʺHealing Plantʺ OR Herbolaria OR ʺHome Remediesʺ OR ʺHome Remedyʺ OR ʺIndigenous Medicineʺ OR ʺPharmaceutical Plantsʺ OR Pharmacognosy OR Phytotherapy OR ʺPlant Extractsʺ OR ʺPlantas Curativasʺ OR ʺPlantas medicinaisʺ OR ʺPlantas medicinalesʺ OR ʺPharmaceutical Plantʺ  OR “Prácticas Complementarias e Integradoras” OR “Practicas de Salud Complementarias e Integradoras” OR “Practicas de Salud Integradoras y Complementarias” OR “Practicas Integradoras y Complementarias” OR “Práticas Complementares e Integrativas” OR “Práticas de Saúde Complementares e Integrativas” OR “Praticas de Saude Integrativas e Complementares” OR “Práticas Integrativas e Complementares” OR “Praticas integrativas” OR “Remedios Caseiros” OR “Remedios Caseros” OR “Remedios Folcloricos” OR “Remedios Populares” OR ʺTerapias Alternativasʺ OR ʺTerapias Complementariasʺ OR ʺTraditional Medicineʺ

In the second phase, a thematic structure was used with more than 80 different search strategies to collect all the documents of the TCIM field. Each one of the strategies for each topic of the thematic structure was elaborated with the DeSC, MeSH descriptors, and also a list of keywords in order to collect the most existing articles and documents. This new collection was developed in March 2018, and since then it gets actualized every day.


The MOSAICO Database

Logo Base de datos MOSAICOThe database for Traditional, Complementary and Integrative Medicine and related therapies - MOSAICO is a collaborative product of the TCIM Americas Network. The database applies the LILACS methodology for bibliographic description and indexing with the DeCS Vocabulary (the document’s Descriptors in Health Sciences).

The MOSAICO Database includes conventional and non-conventional documents on Traditional, Complementary and Integrative Medicine and related practices -MTCI-, in the context of the Region of the Americas. The documents in the database are of a technical-scientific nature.

The MOSAICO Database seeks to make visible those investigations, and technical documents that are not indexed in other databases, but whose content contributes to the implementation of the TCIM in health systems and services, and constitutes a tool for health professionals, both in clinical practice, as well as in academic settings, and in health decision-making.

Access to the MOSAICO Database is free and can be through the VHL MTCI Americas.

The main selection criteria for documents applied to the MOSAICO database are:

Thematic Coverage: Traditional, Complementary and Integrative Medicine, covering all types of complementary and integrative therapies.

Types of documents: journal articles, thesis, books, book chapters, technical reports, government documents, legislation, educational material, papers presented at congresses and scientific-technical events, and all types of non-conventional literature.

Chronological Coverage: There is no chronological restriction, preference given to the entry of more recent material to contribute to the topicality of the database.

Geographical Coverage: TCIM documents will be included in the context of the Americas, regardless of the nationality of the authors or country of publication of the document, as well as the documents produced by the Pan American Health Organization (PAHO), its Programs and Specialized Centers.

Idiomatic Coverage: Documents in Spanish, Portuguese, English, French that are official PAHO´s languages, will be considered for inclusion, but  MOSAICO can include documents of other languages and dialects.

Full-text availability: Priority given to the registration of documents with access to the full text available.

To see more information and the Selection Criteria of the MOSAICO Database.

Promotional Materials

In this section, the promotional materials of the VHL MTCI Americas are available to be used by all the members of the TCIM Americas Network to share the VHL TCIM Americas project in different spaces, such as congresses, academic events, or research, among others.

If you are not yet part of the MTCI Americas Network, and you are interested in belonging or in helping to disseminate this project, please write to our contact.

Presentations Promotional materials
  • Poster of the VHL MTCI Americas (front - back) (Spanish)
  • Banner of the VHL MTCI Americas (pdf) (Spanish)
  • Bookmarker (front - back) (Spanish)
  • Poster of the Brazilian Academic Integrative Health Consortium (Portuguese)
Videos Gallery In this section, you will find the memories of the different activities were the VHL TCIM Americas and the TCIM Americas Network have participated.

Image gallery

In this section, photos of the events, meetings and other activities that the TCIM Americas Network has participated are available.
If you are part of the TCIM Americas Network, share your photos with us via e-mail: bvsmtci@gmail.com, for publication in the VHL TCIM Americas.
Image gallery